Every few months a version of the same story makes the rounds on LinkedIn and business podcasts. An owner runs a company doing about $50 million a year, puts every expense she can on a card, and "pays herself $300,000 a year in credit card points, tax free." The comments fill up with people asking which card she uses.
We run a points system on our own Amazon inventory spend, so we read these posts closely (and a little jealously). The idea underneath is real. The story also skips a few problems, and the last one can cost more than the points are worth.
The part that's true
Big card spend earns big points. A company putting $15 to $20 million a year through cards that earn 1.5 points per dollar collects 22 to 30 million points. Redeemed at a cent each, that's $225,000 to $300,000. The arithmetic holds.
The strongest version of the claim is better than the headline. She isn't cashing a $300,000 cheque. She's using points for family travel she'd otherwise pay for out of her salary. To have $300,000 left after tax at an overall tax rate near 45 percent, she'd need about $545,000 of salary. That's why the story spreads.
The $300,000 is priced at first class
Points stories almost always value a redemption at the cash price of the seat. Say a first-class return to Tokyo lists at $18,000 and books for 140,000 points. On paper that's about 13 cents a point. Almost nobody booking it with points would pay $18,000 cash.
The honest value is what she'd have spent otherwise, maybe $6,000 for business class or $1,500 for economy. Price the same year of trips that way and the $300,000 often shrinks by half or more. We cover realistic per-point values and the break-even formula in the points flywheel post.
The points came off a business expense
Rewards earned on purchases are usually treated as a discount on what you bought. That's why most people never pay tax on them. A discount on company purchases belongs to the company, though. If the business deducts the full price of its inventory and travel, and the owner also takes the discount home as free trips, the same dollars get used twice.
At small scale the amounts are easy to miss, but the rule is the same. At $300,000 a year, an auditor can trace it from the card and rewards statements.
Calling it pay makes it worse
"She pays herself in points" is about the worst way to describe the setup to a tax authority. The CRA's own loyalty points guidance says points the company controls are a taxable benefit when an employee redeems them personally, and that even points on a personal card lose their tax-free treatment when the arrangement looks like an alternative form of pay. For an owner, it's taxed as a shareholder or employee benefit, depending on the facts. Jones and Cosman, our accounting firm, covers the Canadian side on their Amazon accountant page.
US sellers get no free pass either. In Anikeev v. Commissioner (2021), a couple went to Tax Court over roughly $313,000 in Amex rewards on personal cards, most of it from buying gift cards. The court treated the gift card rewards as a discount but taxed the rewards from money orders and debit card reloads. Company points paying for family trips is a weaker case than theirs.
What a sensible owner does with business points
- Keep business points in the business and spend them on business travel: trade shows, supplier visits, the trip to check on your prep center. There's no benefit question, and it cuts a real cost.
- Value each redemption at what you'd have paid. Track balances and savings in AwardWallet or a spreadsheet.
- Pay yourself properly through salary or dividends, planned with an accountant. Points are a perk on top of that.
- Put more spend on cards where the fee math works. Supplier invoices can go through Plastiq or Chexy, as we laid out in how to pay Amazon suppliers with a credit card.
Run that way, a seller doing $2 million a year can still fly business class to the Canton Fair on points. It just won't make a viral post.
Frequently asked questions
Are credit card rewards taxable for a business?
Rewards earned on purchases are usually treated as a discount on what was bought, so earning them isn't normally taxed. The answer changes when business points pay for personal travel or get converted to cash. In Canada, talk to your accountant before redeeming company points for yourself.
Can I pay myself in credit card points instead of salary?
Not tax free. Redeeming company-controlled points for personal use is generally a taxable benefit, and an arrangement built to replace pay is the case the CRA singles out. Pay yourself through salary or dividends and use points as a business travel tool.
Can my company use its points for my business trips?
Yes, and it's the cleanest use for them. Points spent on real business travel cover a cost the company would have paid anyway. Keep a note of each trip's purpose with the booking.
How much card spend does it take to earn $300,000 in points?
About $20 million a year at 1.5 points per dollar and a cent a point. Viral numbers usually price the points at first-class fares, which makes the spend look much smaller.
We write about building, running, and selling an Amazon business from wherever you live. Join the newsletter.