When a buyer first floats a number for your Amazon business, every instinct says to argue about the number. I did it myself the first time someone asked about one of ours. For a Canadian seller, the price is the second question. The first one is worth more: who is actually selling, you or your company?
Two sellers, two very different deals
If you sell on Amazon through a Canadian corporation, there are two ways to hand the business over. In a share sale, you personally sell the shares of the corporation, and the buyer walks away owning the company, the seller account inside it, the inventory, the trademarks and every old liability it ever picked up. In an asset sale, your corporation stays yours and sells the pieces: the listings, the brand, the stock and the supplier relationships.
Buyers of Amazon businesses almost always want the asset version. It leaves your company's history with you, so they aren't inheriting a chargeback dispute from 2023. Most FBA deals get papered as asset purchase agreements for that reason.
Sellers, if they knew to ask, would usually want the share version. The money lands in your own hands in one step, and a Canadian owner selling qualifying shares may be able to use the lifetime capital gains exemption, which an asset sale never gets. That is as deep as this post goes on tax. Our accounting firm, Jones & Cosman, lays out the full picture in its exit planning guide, including the exemption and how each structure gets taxed.
Why the gap is bigger than the haggling
Put round numbers on it. A buyer offers $1,000,000 for your brand. You push hard and get them to $1,050,000.
Now compare how the two structures treat the first million. In an asset sale, your corporation receives the money and pays its tax on the gain, and then you pay tax again when you move what's left out of the company and into your own account. In a share sale, the money comes to you directly, with one layer of tax, and part of it may be sheltered altogether. When the shares qualify for the exemption, the difference between those two paths on a seven-figure deal can easily be larger than the fifty grand you just won on price.
The exact figures depend on your province, how long you've held the shares and what else sits inside the corporation. That's the accountant's job, and it's why the structure conversation comes before the price conversation, not after you've signed a letter of intent.
What this looks like at the deal table
Knowing the two structures changes how you negotiate. A few moves:
- Ask the buyer which structure they're assuming before you react to the number. A $1,000,000 share offer and a $1,000,000 asset offer are not the same offer.
- If they insist on assets, that's a price conversation. Sellers often ask for more on an asset deal to cover what the structure costs them, and experienced buyers expect it.
- If a share sale is on the table, the seller account stays inside the company, the new owners update the ownership and contact details with Amazon (expect identity re-verification), and the buyer takes on the whole history, warts included.
- If it's an asset deal, plan the migration. The buyer usually works from their own Seller Central account, and your listings, brand registry, trademarks and ad accounts move across over four to twelve weeks. Clean books make that handover far less painful, which is the point of our acquisition-ready checklist.
The aggregators still buying and most broker-listed buyers want assets. An individual operator is sometimes open to shares, which can be a reason to pick one sales channel over another.
Where this fits in the bigger plan
Decide what you're selling, then decide what it's worth with our valuation post, then go find the buyer. The whole sequence lives in our guide to selling your Amazon business. Sellers who do it backwards learn about the share-versus-asset question from the buyer's lawyer, the most expensive classroom there is. If you're within a year or two of selling, Jones & Cosman runs an exit strategy call for this stage.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sell my Amazon seller account on its own?
Not really. The account stays with the company that owns it, so it only changes hands when the company does, in a share sale. After an asset sale the buyer runs the business from their own account and the listings and brand assets move over.
Do I have to sell through a corporation to get the share sale option?
Yes. A sole proprietor has no shares to sell, so every sale is an asset sale. If a sale is a few years out, that's a conversation to have with your accountant this year, not the year you sell.
Will a buyer walk away if I ask for a share sale?
Some will, and most will push back, because it means taking on your company's history. Many deals land on an asset sale with a higher price instead, which is fine if you knew what the structure cost you first.
Does this apply if I sell on Amazon.com from Canada?
Yes. The question follows the corporation, not the marketplace. A Canadian company selling on Amazon.com faces the same share-versus-asset choice.
We write about building, running, and eventually selling an Amazon business from wherever you happen to live. Join the newsletter.


